From the same archive

Invited talk 2: Nicholas Cook, Researching creative performance: a report from CMPCP - Nicholas Cook

October 10, 2015 55 min

The Application of Foundational Principles of Critique. Génétique to the Analysis of Music Sketches: Problems and Solutions - Michael Dias

October 10, 2015 32 min

Analysing improvisation: A composer-improviser role in the Gruppo di Improvvisazione Nuova Consonanza and New Phonic Art Experience - Ingrid Pustijanac

October 10, 2015 33 min

From process to performance: Compositional process as framework for text-based improvisation in Henry Brant’s ‘Instant Music’ - Joel Hunt

October 10, 2015 27 min

From fragments to final works: Shostakovich and the creative process - Laura Kennedy

October 10, 2015 29 min

Looking at, and listening to, musical features: creativity in score preparation - Vanessa Hawes, Kate Gee

October 10, 2015 30 min

The speculative ear tracks musical creativity: Adorno’s response to the dilemmas of hearing the new - Shierry Nicholsen

October 10, 2015 28 min

How are creation networks configured in contemporary Brazilian opera? - Talita Takeda

October 10, 2015 26 min

Agata Zubel’s Not I at the festival Warsaw Autumn (2014): Tracing collaborative dimensions of the creative process within the festival context - Monika Zyla

October 10, 2015 30 min

Codification of the Concord Sonata: Editorial and performative composition - Robin Preiss

October 10, 2015 30 min

Roundtable 2: Pierre-Michel Menger, The Economics of Creativity (Harvard University Press, 2014) - Nicholas Cook, Howard S. Becker, Georgina Born, Pierre Michel Menger

October 10, 2015 01 h 13 min

The Interplay of Various Forms of Artistic Knowing - Tasos Zembylas

October 10, 2015 23 min

Comparative Sketch Studies and the "Hidden Concepts" of the creative process in music - Fabian Czolbe

October 10, 2015 26 min

Musical Grammar and the Creative Process - Lodewijk Muns

October 10, 2015 36 min

Learning From Our Mistakes in Tonal Jazz Improvisation - Stefan Caris Love

October 10, 2015 26 min

The Art of the Trio: Improvisation, Interaction, and Intermusicality in the Jazz Piano Trio - Michael Mackey

October 10, 2015 24 min

Material, Interaction, Attitude and Music within Improvising Processes: A Sociological Model - Silvana Karina Figueroa-Dreher

October 10, 2015 29 min

‘Situation’ and ‘Problem Situation’ in the interaction of music and philosophy in antagonisme by Xavier Darasse on a text by Alain Badiou - Matthew Lorenzon

October 10, 2015 26 min

Marc-André Dalbavie, du produit au processus. Un regard sur la genèse d’« acoustiques virtuelles » à partir de partitions et d’écrits du compositeur - Ernesto Donoso

October 10, 2015 32 min

Researching creative performance: a report from CMPCP - Nicholas Cook

October 10, 2015 55 min

Finding common ground in divergent compositional aesthetics: Elliott Carter’s and Luigi Nono’s analyses of Arnold Schoenberg’s op. 31 - Laura Emmery

October 10, 2015 27 min

Comment Henri Dutilleux a incorporé le sérialisme à son langage harmonique - Analyse de Métaboles et Tout un monde lointain - Shigeru Fujita

October 10, 2015 26 min

Between sports and ideology: Janáček’s Sinfonietta and Petrželka’s Štafeta

0:00/0:00

The paper is an attempt for reconstruction of coding (creative) and decoding (reading) process, both dependent on temporary collective imaginative patterns, which funded the historic-ontological status of two significant works of the Czech interwar music: Štafeta [The Relay] (1927), a string quartet by Janáček’s pupil Vilém Petrželka (1889–1967), and Sinfonietta (1926) by Leoš Janáček (1854–1928). It is based on two case-studies, which emphasize the relationships between both of these two works – but also other texts and discursive practices, which formed their historical creation and reception – and sports, typical cultural phenomenon of the 1920s. Both compositions are likely to be included in the temporary wave of compositions reflecting and representing sports, such as Honegger’s Rugby, Half-time and La Bagarre by Bohuslav Martinů, Start and Stadion by Pavel Bořkovec, because they use very similar musical-semantic methods. The paper also focuses on ideological aspects of creation and reception of these compositions, especially in the relation to the official ideology of the First Czechoslovak Republic and to the ideology of interwar avant-gardes, which was to a large extent subversive against the former one.

Methodological background of my paper is represented by the critical theories of Michel Foucault, "new historicism" in literary studies (Bolton 2007) and post- structuralistically oriented Anglo-American musicology after 1980 (Burnham 1995; De Nora 1997). While the methodological base of both case studies is the same, the concrete used methods are different: the case-study on Štafeta is focused on a semio-pragmatic analysis of the composition itself, whereas this substantially subjective interpretation is emended by the analysis of context; on the other hand, in the case-study on Sinfonietta I have focused on the analysis of textual traces of receptive acts (the context) and interpreted these traces with regard to the text of the composition.

Štafeta was a work of art belonging to the official "democratic" culture of the First Czechoslovak Republic, which was intended to consolidate different social classes of the young state. The popular potential of the composition depended on its three main qualities: (1) a realization of formal "relief" of Schoenbergian string quartet, in a way of song cycle with string quartet accompaniment; (2) the musicalisation of poetry by Jiří Wolker, the most popular temporary poet, whose posthumous cult, initiated mainly by upper-middle class, was culminating when Štafeta was composed; (3) the comprehensibility, based on such semantic and syntactic progressions which were cognitively amenable for relatively wide corps of temporary recipients. Štafeta had however also the potency to claim the status of avant-garde work of art, thanks to exploitation of typically avant-garde structuring methods and contextual circumstances of its origin, performance and reception.

In a close-up semio-pragmatic analysis, I have shown that the creation and reading of this composition was basically determined by two main imaginative factors, sports and collectivism, which were strongly bounded in temporary social discourses. The representations of sport, which is semantic relevant aspect of the historical content of Štafeta, is – similar to other expressions of 1920s mentality – jointed with the representations of unbounded sexuality. Just like in other temporary "sport compositions" (Bateman 2009), mainly the motional aspect of sport is represented here, using motorial music structures and other convenient methods of the late 19th century programmatic music. Structure of this composition contains intensive and extensive semantic impulses, which, as I will show, are the two conceptual patterns in the very basis of the process of creation and also reading of the piece. The intensive one relates to structural regularization by the dominant of "running model" and principle of rhythmic ostinato. The extensive one refers to public relay races, carnival feasts (Bachtin 1971; Gurevič 1996) of recycling of the collective national body of the First Czechoslovak Republic. According to these factors, the composition tended to be read as an ideological impetus to faith in collective "new man".

Janáček’s Sinfonietta functioned in ideological practices of interwar Czechoslovakia mainly as an apotheosis of three important aspects of the official ideology: (1) the idea of paramilitary youth sport and gymnastic movement called Sokol [Falcon], (2) Czechoslovakian army and (3) the idea of "new man" and new republic – his Umwelt, which was produced by him as well as producing him. The composition was presumably created and read according to these intentions, and thence its temporary content oscillated between these three positions. According to a detailed analysis of the discourse on Sinfonietta and its author, the group of contents ascribed to this composition had a relatively coherent, systematic form in the interwar Czechoslovakia, whereas the dominant modus of reading of Sinfonietta was determined chiefly by premiere of the composition during the mass gymnastic action called Sokol-Rally in 1926. The composition was also created and read as a representation of sports, as a realization of "aesthetics of disinfection" (Česálková 2006), which was typical of both official and avant-garde culture of the 1920s. All these correspondences between intended and empirical content of Sinfonietta were in principle provided by the discourse of temporary music criticism.

speakers

information

Type
Séminaire / Conférence
duration
26 min
date
October 10, 2015
program note
TCPM 2015

IRCAM

1, place Igor-Stravinsky
75004 Paris
+33 1 44 78 48 43

opening times

Monday through Friday 9:30am-7pm
Closed Saturday and Sunday

subway access

Hôtel de Ville, Rambuteau, Châtelet, Les Halles

Institut de Recherche et de Coordination Acoustique/Musique

Copyright © 2022 Ircam. All rights reserved.